No announcement yet.

SF Marina Plan Scrapped


  • SF Marina Plan Scrapped

    A plan to relocate 200 boat slips and expand a boat harbor in the Marina has been effectively scrapped after San Francisco supervisors voted unanimously Tuesday to block the Recreation and Park Department from controlling the site.

    The controversial plan, which would have relocated the harbor in front of Marina Green and obstructed views there, has been a hot topic among Marina residents, many of whom showed up en masse to protest against it.

    Despite the intense public pushback, the Recreation and Park Commission voted unanimously to advance plans for the project in October with an amendment that staff must first conduct a study to determine how much the department can reduce the number of slips in the West Harbor while ensuring the project is still financially feasible. It did not adopt a final design.

    The project sprung from a lawsuit settlement between the city and Pacific Gas and Electric Co. requiring that the utility pay up to $190 million to clean up the East Harbor, which was contaminated by a power plant that closed a century ago.

    The parks department has said that it needs to expand the one area of the harbor and relocate the boat slips because it needs the revenue from rentals to make sure the marina is self-sustaining. But supervisors argued there’s a way to make the project pencil out by using philanthropy and other money.

    The project plan approved by the Rec and Park Commission would have used the PG&E funds to clean up Gashouse Cove and expand the West Harbor. A report by the Budget and Legislative Analyst says that if the remediation project does not proceed as planned, operating revenue for the department would fall short of expenditures by more than $1 million per year, which would require a general fund subsidy.

    Supervisor Ahsha Safai pointed to the city’s successful effort to raise funds for the remediation of China Basin on the southern waterfront as an example of one way the city can preserve the Marina yacht harbors and do the environmental work that’s needed.

    Supervisors now want Rec and Park to go back to the drawing board and preserve as much of the existing harbor as possible, arguing it’s a key part of the ecosystem of water sports in San Francisco, including swimming, sailing and rowing.

    Supervisors Aaron Peskin and Connie Chan, along with Safai, cosponsored legislation that would prohibit Rec and Park from using city funds to design, plan, review or implement a project that “would extend the eastern boundary of the West Harbor Marina by more than approximately 150 feet from its current location.”

    A spokesperson for the parks department said the legislation will thwart the department’s ability to consider all its options for the project. Safai said the legislation is about “preserving uses, not views” and pledged to dip into the bay himself this weekend in honor of this piece of San Francisco history.

    “This is about preserving a majestic space San Franciscans have used for generations of rowers, swimmers and sailors,” Safai said.

    Supervisor Matt Dorsey, who represents Treasure Island, where residents also have deep ties to bay recreation, said the Marina needs to be preserved as it is now to ensure that there is “equitable access” to the bay.

    The group Keep the Waterfront Open told the Chronicle in a statement it’s grateful that the board “heard us.”

    “In a commercial world such as ours ‘unproductive’ public spaces such as this are always at risk,” the statement said. “Our grassroots effort demonstrated that the open waterfront of the Marina Green is valuable to so many residents throughout the city.”

    The Recreation and Park Department said in a statement that it will now “design a Marina to comply with the ordinance” as well as the settlement agreement and rules from all the other regulatory agencies.

    “We expect the practical effects of this ordinance to include: the elimination of the fuel dock and breakwater, reduction of approximately 200 slips and a continued annual dredging obligation that costs between $600,000 and $1 million,” the statement says. “As a result, slip holders can expect to see berthing fees increase by 20% to 30% in the near future.”

    Danielle Echeverria contributed to this report.

    Reach Aldo Toledo:

    S.F. boat harbor relocation scrapped after opponents fight project (
      Posting comments is disabled.

    Latest Articles


    • Making Tracks South Of The Border
      by Photoboy
      PV2024 Day 5:
      San Diego, CA (February 26, 2024) Most boats on the course are about 24 hours behind last year’s record-setting pace. Compared with their 2022 position at this same elapsed time, Rio 100 and BadPak are roughly 200 miles short. Such Fast, a Thursday starter, is about 140 miles short of last year’s Monday morning location.



      Yesterday, 05:10 PM
    • Under 150 NM For Caudrelier To Finish!
      by Photoboy
      The last hours at sea for ARKEA ULTIM CHALLENGE-Brest leader Charles Caudrelier as he seeks to close out solo multihull round the world race win.

      A tantalising three hundred miles from the finish line of the first ARKEA ULTIM CHALLENGE-Brest solo ULTIM round the world race, French skipper Charles Caudrelier spent his 50th birthday and his 50th day of racing since leaving Brest on Sunday 7th January keeping his giant blue and white Verdier designed ULTIM Maxi Edmond
      Yesterday, 03:47 PM
    • Delamare Wins, Cole's Northerly Ascension Continues Her March Into History Books
      by Photoboy

      Today February 24th at 14:03 UTC, 3:03 pm local time, after 147d 1h 3m 37s at sea, Philippe Delamare on Mowgli has won the Global Solo Challenge 2023/2024, first competitor to complete his circumnavigation by the three great capes, solo and non stop. The sea state was very challenging with waves over 6 meters even close to the finish line. Philippe has faced a serious storm to complete his circumnavigation and 2 days ago in the building seas he was knocked down...
      Yesterday, 12:28 PM
    • The End Of One Journey Sparks Desire To Continue The Objective
      by Photoboy
      Long, but final debrief.

      A bit over 10 days ago, my participation in the Global Solo Challenge came to an abrupt and unfortunate end when I dismasted in the South Atlantic Ocean. I had just written a downtrodden and somber blog entry a day or two before where I expressed how challenging and inhospitable the South Atlantic Ocean had been to me.

      Sure enough, she finished me off shortly after that entry. While navigating northward
      02-25-2024, 11:11 AM
    • Caudrelier Takes Safety Stop In The Azores
      by Photoboy
      With less than 1,200 miles to go to the finish of the ARKEA ULTIM CHALLENGE-Brest, Charles Caudrelier on the Maxi Edmond de Rothschild, leader of the race since the end of January, has elected to take shelter in the Azores, thereby making a technical stopover.

      The “24-hour stopover timer” was started by race management at 0504hrs UTC. His objective is to avoid a big depression approaching from the south of Iceland which is set to make the Bay of Biscay “impassable”
      02-23-2024, 02:06 PM
    • A Fast Pit Stop In Brazil For Banque Populaire
      by Photoboy

      After a little more than 48 hours of technical stopover in Rio de Janeiro, ARKEA ULTIM CHALLENGE-Brest skipper Armel Le Cleac'h and his ULTIM Maxi Banque Populaire XI have returned to the race track. He docked out from Rio at a little after 1630hrs UTC and resumed racing in third place at 1738hrs UTC.

      Thanks to great cooperation from the authorities in France and Brazil the Banque Populaire XI technical team were able to replace the two rudders damaged in the South
      02-18-2024, 02:37 PM